So Cal Real Estate News

One of the many unknowns in the current real estate market/meltdown/crisis/challenge (take your pick) is what the government can and will do to get us out of the mess they helped get us into (see “How we got into this mess“).

Monday night  Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke, speaking at Columbi’a Business School, pushed Congress to act for the sake of us all:

High rates of delinquency and foreclosure can have substantial spillover effects on the housing market, the financial markets and the broader economy. Therefore, doing what we can to avoid preventable foreclosures is not just in the interest of lenders and borrowers. It’s in everybody’s interest.

We think he’s right on the money on that one.    (For the APs report on the speech, click here.)

The challenge is how to correct the problem without bankrupting us all.

On the one hand, there are probably well over a million homeowners who now owe significantly more on their mortgage than their home is worth.  On the other hand, as Tevye would say, there are also no doubt tens of millions of Americans who owe significantly more on their car loan than their car is worth.

Do we really want to set a precedent that the government will bail people out of their own stupid decisions?  Nobody held a gun to anyone’s head to buy a home.  Most of them signed disclosure documents detailing out their loan’s ridiculous terms somewhere in the fine print.

But I know a rocket scientist (literally) that signed those documents and ended up over $100,000 upside down with an obscene payment.  Yes, he “trusted” his real estate agent/lender (bad sign!), who promised she’d get them a refi out of the loan (oops, guess she forgot to mention the prepayment penalty let alone the potential for decline in value).

I also have heard of lenders who had full time “signers” who supplied signatures on behalf of their borrowers for those subprime loans, whether their borrowers knew it or not.  (Now that I think of it, I don’t recall signing loan docs on some refi loans my wife & I did a while back.  Hmmm.)  Oh, did I mention that those disclosure documents were written in a language many of the borrowers didn’t speak (English)?

Bernanke’s taking a different approach.  Something like “we’re all in this boat together, and if we don’t start bailing these people out, we’ll all sink together.”  And he may be right.

Most commentators take this as a direct push from Bernanke for something akin to Rep. Barney Frank’s proposal for broad based foreclosure relief, which would include write-downs of the principal balance for some upside-down homeowners.  (For interesting details on Frank’s bill & the Bernanke connection, check out this post from TheHill.com).

How this all works could get messy, or it could help us all move on.  Or it could sink us all.  Action-reaction.  Unintended consequences.  Like the Fed dropping short term rates so low the dollar drops and inflation picks up & long-term rates (including fixed mortgages) go up.  That just happened.

Or, as my friend in Tennessee, Vince Thrasher, would say, “Hey, ‘The Fed dropping short term rates so low the dollar drops and inflation picks up & long-term rates (including fixed mortgages) go up’ just happened!”

Kind of like the fed dropping interest rates to save the economy after 9/11 and creating a housing bubble.  Yeah, that just happened, too, although Ben wasn’t driving the bus into the ditch back then.

Maybe it’s just time to let things just run their course.  It’s beginning to look like the longer the government tries to put off or minimize a downturn, the worse it becomes.

I’m still hoping an orderly debate may produce a moderate middle course that will at least partially mitigate some of the damage as we move forward.

We’re also advising our sellers to take advantage of the current spring mini-surge if they want to take the most conservative course of action.  And we’re advising our buyers to be patient, negotiate aggressively, and be sure to lock in a 30 year fixed loan they can live with on a home they won’t have to sell any time soon.

Just more evidence that what we said last November is still true:  We’re in uncharted territory, and nobody knows what’s ahead (see “How low will prices go?“)

Or, as Bernanke said last night, in our favorite quote, “A widespread decline in home prices, by contrast, is a relatively novel phenomenon, and lenders and servicers will have to develop new and flexible strategies to deal with this issue.”

Actually, they should have developed those new strategies a year or two ago.  Instead of the new and flexible subprime lending strategies they were working on.

As my mom would say, “Better late than never.”  If Bernanke’s concerned, maybe we should be too.

Real estate news is coming fast and furious! I take a weekend off from blogging for Barb’s birthday, & suddenly I’m hammered.

Several interesting items popped up over the last few days I found fascinating. In this post we’ll focus on the our own beloved California Association of Realtor’s headline-grabbing announcement that median prices are expected to drop 24% this year.  (Later, a look at remarks by the Fed’s Bernanke last night.)

It happened at the Disneyland hotel where our own Pacific West Board of Realtors was holding it’s spring “expo” and pep rally on Friday. Sadly, and ironically, as we local Realtors were meeting, a businessman decided to end it all by jumping from one of the hotel’s towers. Shades of the Great Depression. It is my understanding he was not a Realtor, surprisingly.

But some Realtors probably thought about joining him after they heard from CAR’s Deputy Chief Economist, Robert Kleinhenz, who revised the Association’s 2008 forecast for median home prices statewide. In March, CAR predicted a 9.5% drop for the year. Kleinhenz almost tripled that 9.5%, to a 24% drop. No wonder his boss, California Association of Realtor’s Chief Economist Leslie Appleton-Young, asked him to give the speech. (Leslie was the one out with 9.5% for the year in March, doubling her 4.5% October figure, which we thought was too conservative. Looks like when she ran the numbers again late in April, she just handed the sheet to poor Bob Kleinhenz on her way out the door to advise some poor businessman staying elsewhere in the hotel.)

But wait a minute–that may not be as bad as it seems. Dataquick’s most recent statewide median prices showed a 26% price drop for March 2008 from March 2007, which was when Dataquick’s price median peaked. Dataquick indicated “about half” of that drop was due to a shift in the market to more sales of lower priced homes. (For a detailed post on the problems with Dataquick’s median numbers, check out “Two big problems with DataQuick’s median prices.”)

So if you read between the lines, Kleinhenz, who apparently is playing “bad cop” to the missing Leslie Appleton-Young’s “good cop,” is implying that the worst is behind us. 2007 ended with CAR reporting a statewide median for Single Family homes of $476,000, and their latest number, for March 2008 is down to $414,000! (Click here for CAR’s press release on their March numbers) . That’s actually lower than the $424,000 median average for the year they’re now predicting.

As a 28 year CAR member, I picked up the phone to talk to old Bob himself, but discovered he was in Sacramento giving another speech today. Something about a statewide tour sponsored by Pierce Brothers Mortuary.

In any case, his capable associate, Oscar Wei was available to assist me, and he confirmed my suspicion that CAR now thinks the worst is behind us: “Hopefully, and that’s a lot of hope, things should be bottoming out soon in terms of price,” he told me.

That agrees with Oscar’s bosses comments last Friday at the resort formerly known as “The Happiest Place on Earth: “We do think this is the year we’re going to see our low point for sales. … Monthly sales have already bottomed out.” Also “All these numbers are going to stabilize and slightly improve. … We’re basically climbing above the liquidity crunch to pre-liquidity numbers.”

Well, I may be paying Bob & Oscar’s salaries, but I’m not quite ready to eat their breadsticks. With homes entering foreclosure still increasing (see “So Cal defaults up again“), and the liquidity problem far from solved, Blair and I are still expecting additional declines in values and sales as we move through fall and winter (See “Predictions 101: Our 2 market cycles“).

That doesn’t mean now may not be a good time to buy if you’re in a position to do so.  Shoot, Bob & Oscar could well be right, and Dave & Blair wrong.  Well, Blair anyway.  In fact, we continue to believe that if you find a home you love at a payment you can live with on a 30 year fixed loan, and you don’t intend to move any time soon, at least write an offer on it.

But if you’re not yet in a position to buy, there’s no need to panic.  While sellers may be less motivated as prices firm, we’re not going to see double digit appreciation any time soon.  And there’s a good chance the bottom may still be a year or two away.

But nobody knows for sure, as we keep saying, much to the annoyance of some of our gentle readers.  (See “How low will prices go?”

That’s what makes So Cal Real Estate so interesting.

What do you think’s next?

Last night Barb, Nate, & I went to see Ben Stein‘s new movie, Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed. It’s a wry, stark, and thought-provoking semi-documentary look at how closed-minded our scientific and educational establishment has become about alternatives to neo-Darwinism.

Maybe closed-mindedness is the default setting of humankind. Something we all have to fight against. I see it all the time in the real estate world. Potential sellers call me, supposedly to find out what the current market value is of their home. Often after I review the data and explain my professional opinion, they proceed to tell me how wrong I am.

“OK,” I think. “Why exactly did you ask me to do the research if you already knew the answer?” Actually, it’s simple. They wanted me to confirm what they thought they already knew. Maybe to show the spouse how wrong he/she was. Combination of pride and self-interest. (See reason #1 of “5 reasons NOT to pick a listing agent” for more on this.) “I made up my mind; don’t bother me with the facts.”

Somehow, it seems that this human bent towards closed-mindedness is often more pronounced in those who are in positions of authority. (For examples, consider Washington, D.C., Sacramento, or, most likely, your boss.) Truly successful leaders must fight hard to keep an open mind. Because power and closed-mindedness is a very dangerous combination (see Adolf Hitler, Vietnam War, or sub-prime lending).

Well, according to Ben’s new movie, an extreme version of that sort of closed mindedness has invaded much of the scientific community. Not just “I made up my mind. . . ” but “I made up my mind & yours too!”

Closed mindedness to the point where even mentioning an opposing viewpoint can get a professor fired. Talk about “academic freedom.”

A very thought provoking movie, with a little of Stein’s wry humor thrown in. I highly recommend it. Click here and insert your zip code for showtimes.

And keep an open mind.

(more…)